Sweetening the Sugar Industry Towards Market Reforms

By Prof. Dr. Muhammad Sarwar Khan
Former Dean Agriculture and Vice Chancellor of the University of Agriculture, Faisalabad.

Pakistan, an agriculture based country that contributes 24% to GDP and ranks 7th in the world in sugarcane production by growing sugarcane on 1.2 million hectares, crushes nearly 80 million tonnes every year and exports refined sugar regularly since 2005 and is 2nd on the list after Brazil in indigenous development of GM sugarcane to protect ecosystem and farmers’ input token. Sugarcane is becoming a more profitable and attractive crop for farmers by adopting mechanized farming and intercropping approaches; however, it is often criticized for being a water intensive rather than a carbon scrubbing crop. Cultivation of multiple crops may reduce this crop based toll as well.

It is imperative to empower farmers with the autonomy to select crops best suited for their fields under prevailing climatic stresses with choice market access. That this approach works is proof already exists: the rice and corn industries are successfully meeting domestic demand while generating foreign exchange. Notably, the rice industry broke historic export records by touching approximately $4.0 billion in exports, a surge driven directly by government policies that has allowed the sector to operate under free market principles. Extending the same deregulation to the sugar industry would eliminate market distortions, encourage sustainable crop choices, and unlock similar export and growth potential.

The sugar industry is urging the government to allow higher exports, requesting permission to export one million MT of sugar. Additionally, PSMA is advocating for deregulation of industry. To address the industry’s concerns, the prime minister constituted a deregulation and market reforms committee which has held a series of meetings with PSMA, farmers’ associations, and provincial governments to liberalize the highly controlled sector and transition towards market orientated reforms. Recently, under the chairmanship of the prime minister, the committee agreed to a phased deregulation of the sugar industry; however, the government of Sindh is pushing to extend the timeline of these phases.

Historical agro ecological zones with fixed cropping patterns were extensively utilized to maximize crop production benefits. The rising temperatures and erratic rains have significantly disrupted these zones and cropping patterns across Pakistan, necessitating redefining them. Cotton has reduced its area significantly in Punjab, while other major crops have increased their acreage. The increase in sugarcane acreage is only 0.49 million compared with rice (2.7 million) and maize (1.7 million acres). As far as water usage of these crops is concerned, sugarcane uses approximately 5.043 million liters per acre, which is significantly lower than the wheat rice crop cycle (7.011 million liters per acre) and is higher than the wheat cotton cycle (4.059 million liters per acre), reflecting that rice is the water intensive crop. Precision irrigation practices such as drip irrigation and improved agronomic practices, raised bed intercropping, definitely reduce single crop based toll.

The sugar industry clustering in Southern Punjab has favored the farmers and compelled the mills to opt for corporate farming similar to the potato crop. Furthermore, sugarcane gives farmers assured payment from sugar mills and less risk from pests. The cotton area decreased in Punjab by around 2.7M acres between 2010 and 2025; this is partly because of crop failure and high risk of pests (chewing and sucking) and diseases, CLCV (Cotton Leaf Curl Virus). Resultantly, farmers started growing high return crops with guaranteed payments rather than depending on fluctuating markets.

Pakistan has over 90 sugar mills, but they sit idle for almost 8 months a year because crushing season lasts only 100 to 120 days. To improve this industry, we need to extend cultivation across both the autumn and spring seasons to keep mills running longer. In addition to controlling the supply, the government fixes sugar prices while completely ignoring the environmental value farmers bringing to the table, like saving water, trapping carbon, and stopping field burning to clean our air. True reform requires recognizing these eco contributions and allowing for flexible cropping zones.

PSMA has requested that the government permit the export of approximately 1 million metric tonnes (MT) of refined sugar, whereas the government has approved only 200,000 MT, the quota the PSMA has rejected as insufficient. To resolve the deadlock, it is imperative that the government, PSMA, farmer associations’ and consumers’ representatives engage in an inclusive and transparent dialogue. Recently, the Cabinet Committee on the Export of Surplus Sugar, headed by the Deputy Prime Minister, held a series of meetings to review the issue. During its latest session on November 04, 2026, the committee finalized the framework to facilitate surplus exports without disrupting the domestic retail price, though specific details on any revised volume are still awaited. Let’s hope for a judicious export policy that brings in much needed foreign exchange.