They Are Right There With You — And They Are the Most at Risk
Written by Asadullah | 8th semester veterinary student at the Faculty of Veterinary Science, University of Agriculture Faisalabad.
Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!Key Message: During Qurbani season, safety is not only about the animal. Pregnant women, children, elderly family members, and people with weak immune systems also need protection.
We spend a lot of time talking about the animal during Qurbani season. Is it healthy? Is the knife sharp enough? Has it been vaccinated? All of that matters are really genuine. But there is a group of people standing right next to the slaughter area, watching from the doorway, helping carry the meat inside, who almost nobody talks about. The pregnant woman in the house. The four-year-old who wants to see what is happening. The grandfather with his diabetes medication. The cousin who just finished chemotherapy. These people are not just bystanders to Eid. They are, quietly, its most vulnerable participants.
VNV Insight: The article shifts the focus from animal-only safety to household public health, especially for vulnerable people standing close to the Qurbani process.
Pregnant Women Need Special Protection
Let me start with pregnant women, because this is the one that I feel most strongly about. The recommendation that pregnant women should avoid contact with animal blood, raw meat, and birth products during Qurbani is not an overly cautious suggestion from someone who worries too much. It is a clinical position, backed by evidence. Two diseases in particular Brucellosis and Q Fever are both endemic in Pakistani livestock and both have been directly and repeatedly linked to miscarriage, premature birth, and serious maternal complications. Brucellosis spreads through handling infected blood and organs with bare or broken skin. Q Fever spreads through inhaling dust contaminated with the birth fluids or faeces of infected animals. Neither requires a dramatic exposure. A moment of contact is enough.
The difficult truth is that many women in Pakistani households feel they cannot simply step back during Eid so they are there for cooking to do, distribution to manage, family expectations to meet. If you are reading this and there is a pregnant woman in your home, make it easy for her to step back. Take something off her plate. This is not a small thing.
Children Face Biological and Psychological Risks
Children are the next concern, and here the risk is twofold. The first is biological. Children’s immune systems are still developing, which means they are less equipped to fight off zoonotic infections that are transfered from animals to humans. The same exposure that gives an adult a mild fever can put a child in hospital.
The second risk is psychological, and it is one that parents often dismiss too quickly. Research into childhood exposure to animal slaughter is clear that young children particularly those under seven can experience genuine and lasting distress from watching an animal be killed, even in a ritual context they do not fully understand.
This does not mean shielding children from the reality of where meat comes from. It means being thoughtful about proximity, about timing, and about what a child is actually ready to process. Keep them occupied elsewhere during the slaughter itself. Let them participate in the parts of Eid that are joyful and safe.
Elderly and Immunocompromised People Are Also at Risk
For elderly individuals and anyone living with a condition that compromises their immune system like diabetes, heart disease, cancer treatment, long-term steroid use so direct participation in slaughter or raw meat handling carries real risk. These are people whose bodies are less able to mount a defence against bacterial infections like Staphylococcus, E. coli, or Brucella, all of which can be present in a slaughter environment.
Simple Protection: If an elderly family member insists on being involved, the minimum protection is a pair of disposable gloves, a long-sleeved shirt, and thorough handwashing with soap before and after.
If an elderly family member insists on being involved, the minimum protection is a pair of disposable gloves, a long-sleeved shirt, and thorough handwashing with soap before and after. These are not complicated asks. They cost almost nothing.
The Spirit of Qurbani Is Care
The broader point I want to leave you with is this. Eid ul Azha is, at its heart, an act of care so care for what God has given us, care for those around us, care for the less fortunate. Extending that care to the most vulnerable members of your own household is not an interruption of the spirit of Qurbani. It is an expression of it.
The Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلمreminded us to show ihsan, excellence and care in everything we do. The people standing closest to you deserve that care most of all.